Malibu California a group of well tanned surfers had been quietly accessing the beach along a path of sand on private property , real estate assignment help

In Malibu California a group of well tanned surfers had been quietly accessing the beach along a path of sand on private property that went in between several large homes in a gated beachfront community.This had been going on without incident from 1996 through 2004. Then an owner of one of the homes noticed the uninvited guests as trespassers and brought suit to have their access denied.If you were the judge making reasonable assumptions how would you rule with regard to this case.