Shaw V. United States, law homework help

What are the arguments in favor of/against each side in the current case of Shaw V. United States?  Tailor the paper around what are believed to be the significant issues.  The paper does not have to contain legal technicalities; an argument that is persuasive from a philosophical, theoretical, or practical standpoint can be made.  Discuss the case in plain language using the above question as a guide and adding other points of interest such as interesting facts.  The paper should be 2-3 pages, double spaced, provide sources, 12 point font, times new roman.